The FOREIGN movie slum dog milliner got nominations for Oscar. I saw that movie yesterday, and I really think that it is not of that standard. It is good but not the best. and if Oscar is giving to such movie then why not our i.e. Indian movies. there are lots of such good but not the best movies in India.
The answer of this WHY? is hidden in the one and only one truth about the Oscar. The awards are giving to the name of director and producers. If the name of director is like Danny boyel or Richard attenbaro, etc. then the award is yours, the Oscar is giving to the name and not to the real art. I know their techniques and themes are wonder full but I don't think so that our Indian movies are such bellow standard that they cant give a single award to our movies.
And if a movie like slum dog getting nominated then why not traffic signal? why not vastav? they have also shown "REALITY"of India. the truth is behind the name Danny Boyel. The truth is they still hate you. They still want to show that you can't lead the world in any manner. You dont have This capability...............................
I agree with you. In fact I did not like the movie at all. Nothing great.
ReplyDeleteजबरदस्त !!!
ReplyDeleteमी ही या विषयावर एक लेख लिहिला आहे. तो तुम्ही या ठिकाणी वाचू शकता.
http://maalkauns.blogspot.com/2009/02/blog-post_09.html
-अभी
http://shardulee.blogspot.com/2009/02/slumdog-millionaireso-what.html
ReplyDeleteHi Dear ,
ReplyDeleteI red your post about Oscar but i really have doubt about your knowledge of Hollywood movies.. I am totally agreed with that our Indian movies are best. But the examples you mentioned like Vastav & Traffic signle are not that qualities....
Well about the Slumdog I must say the movie is very good in every angle whether it is direction, music, acting, art and everything... and it deserves the Oscar... or why not Jury gave the best film or direction to Benjamin Button who was having 13 nominations this year.....? have you seen all of this movies????? If you really want to know why Oscar has never given to Indian Movies then watch all those hollywood movies who have won the Oscar..... Its not beacuse we are indian they are not giving us the Oscar. Lagaan was a very good movie but why it could not achieved the award then you have to really go and watch " No Mens Land " who grab Oscar that time.....
About Indian Movies do you think The Movie Like Krish or Jodha Akbar are deserving the best films of filmfare ???? Ok Jodha was good but what about Krishhh??? The fact is that, bollywood can not think beyond love stories that's why Krishh always following his girlfriend in whole movies the spider man also do that, but rather than Mary Jane he care about the great responsibilities he is having with the great Power.....
Bollywood have started to make these kind of Sci fi or scintific movies by copying hollywood with lots of songs and love affairs & family dramas but if want to discover the difference between Hollywood & Bollywood then I would like to suggest some movies to you. So if you have enough time then please watch these movies like ,
Gone With Wind,
Terminator,
Schindler's List,
The French Connection,
The City Of god,
Troy,
Gladiator,
A beautiful Mind,
Blood Diamond,
Reservoir Dogs,
An Autumn in New York,
One Flew Over Cuckoo's Nest,
A few Good Men,
Chicago,
Traffic,
Babel,
Citizen Cane,
The Silence Of the Lambs,
And many are there.......
Regards
Deepak Parulekar
09967367720
या सिनेमातून झोपडपट्टीतलं आयुष्य खूपसं आहे तस्सं दाखवायचा प्रामाणिक प्रयत्न केलाय. पण इथे सत्यपरिस्थिती अशीच आहे, तो दोष आपला की त्यांचा? मुंबई भारताची आथिर्क राजधानी आहे असं चित्र जगापुढे बनताना स्लमडॉगसारख्या अवघ्या १२० मिनिटांच्या सिनेमामुळे जागतिक समजाला तडा जात असेल तर तो इथल्या इमेज मेकर्सना खुपणं साहजिकच आहे. सिनेमातून गरिबी दाखवणं म्हणजे केवळ शिलाई मशीनवर कपडे शिवून पैसा कमवणारी आणि त्यातून मुलाला 'गज्जर का हलवा' खाऊ घालणारी बिच्चारी आई इतकाच नाही. किंबहुना हिरॉईनच्या अतिप्रचंड श्रीमंतीचं प्रदर्शन करणारे, मुंबईच्या गरीब चॉकलेट हिरोला स्वप्नात फॉरेन लोकेशन्सवर घेऊन जाणारे गोजिरवाणे सिनेमे पाश्चिमात्य देशात अब्जावधी रुपयांचा नफा मिळवून देतात. हे सिनेमे नक्की भारताची कोणती बाजू जगासमोर मांडतात?... या मंडळींची चीड मान्य जरी केली तरी ती खूप पोकळ वाटत रहाते.
ReplyDeleteसिनेमा हे निखळ मनोरंजनाचं माध्यम आहे. जगात हा सिनेमा पाहून कोण काय विचार करेल याचा डोक्याला जास्त ताण न देता सिनेमावर प्रेम करणाऱ्या प्रत्येकाने एक अप्रतिम कलाकृती म्हणून 'स्लमडॉग मिलेनियर' एकदा तरी पहायलाच हवा. यात इथलं दारिद्य अंडरलाइन करून दाखवलंय, मान्य! पण प्रत्येक गोष्टीला एकाहून अधिक बाजू असतात. आणि मुंबईची एकच बाजू या सिनेमात प्रखरपणे मांडली गेलीय.
इथल्या लोकांनी कितीही आरडा-ओरडा केला तरी ती परिस्थीती बदलणार नाही.
काही बदलायचेच असेल तर झोपडपट्ट्या बदला... त्यांत राहणाऱ्या जनतेचा शैक्षणीक, आर्थिक, सामाजीक स्तर बदला!
निवडणुका नजरेसमोर ठेवुन नेते मंडळींनी धारावीला ’प्रेस्टीज पॉईंट’प्रमाणे जपले आहे. "आशिया खंडातली सगळ्यात मोठ्ठी झोपडपट्टी" असं अभिमानानी सांगितलं जातं. पण "आमच्याकडे झोपड्पट्ट्याच नाहीत" ही बाब अधिक अभिमानाची नाहीये का?
Hope so this will gives a answer of your question.Dont shout on others if u dont get it.Show the world that u r also having that guts to archived it.
Visit:-http://my.opera.com/bharatbanate/blog/
Dear Bharat,
ReplyDeleteYou are very much right and I am 100% agreed with you. See, actually the above guys and all other people who are shouting about slumdog is only because the film was made by a foreign director and grabbed oscars. These guys are OK with Madhur Bhandarkar's Traffic Signal. They don't have any issue about the facts shown in Traffic Signal, but they are proud cause it was made by aan INdian. Same if the Slumdog has made by an Indian then all these guys were very proud.
Nobody cares about the poverty, slums or slumdogs in mumbai. well, including media, politicians, and the bloggers like us has got another topic to chew. Afterall, we all are SLUMDOGS in corporate world.....
Arre pan maza aakshep tya moovie chya navaala naahi aahe, tya daridryachya pradarshanala naahi aahe ki baaki tya dangalichya prasanga baddal hi naahye. Mi to pic baghitala aani to mala oskar chya todicha naahi vaatala, maze vayyaktik mat aahe yaar te. aani mi kaahi sanskrutik mantri naahiye bharatachi ki ya pic var bandi ghatliye. mi phakt maaze mat mazya blog var maandale. aani blogs tyasathich tar asatat na?
ReplyDeleteMala kalat naahi evdha aarada orada ka chalavala aahe sagalyani tya pic baddal?
aani ase mulich naahioye ki slumdog BHARATIYANI banavala asata tar aavadala asata vaigare. ti ek kalakruti mhanoonach naahi aavadali tar tyat naagarikatvacha prashna yeto kuthe? mi mhatalay ki moovie changali aahe pan best naahi. ek sadhisudhi prekshak kinva rasik mhanoon kalakruti changali kinva vaait he tharavanyacha aadhikaar aahe mala.
Hi Maithili,
ReplyDeletePeoples like u shouts that "why the oskar is only to slum dog???".
We said why so?
Before also many movies got oscar bt nobody saying like this that why this movie got oscar,why this?
You have freedom to write anything on u r blog and also express u r thoughts,no doubt on it.